When the Courtroom Meets the Cradle: What Justice Sotomayor’s Custody Dissent Reveals About the Biology of Broken Families...

When the Courtroom Meets the Cradle: What Justice Sotomayor’s Custody Dissent Reveals About the Biology of Broken Families

Watch: Figs O’Sullivan, LMFT explains this.

A high conflict custody battle is a custody dispute where the fight between the parents has become the main event: repeated court filings, constant hostility, serious allegations, and children caught in the middle. What harms children most is not the divorce or the schedule. It is the ongoing war between the two people they love, which their nervous system reads as the ground itself giving way.

The best protection is to keep your kids out of the adult fight, lower the temperature with brief, neutral written communication and a parallel parenting structure, and settle your own body before you act. A judge can decide time and decision making. Only the two of you can decide whether the field your child lives in is safe.

If your custody fight has you rehearsing arguments at 3 a.m., Figlet, my AI relationship coach, is there at 2 in the morning, or right now, to help you think through the next text, the next exchange, or what to say to your kids. Talk it through with Figlet.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor did something this week that rarely happens at the highest court in the land. She publicly condemned her colleagues for turning a blind eye to a child custody tug of war, according to a recent Courthouse News report. The case involved a child pulled between jurisdictions, parents, and legal strategies, with the kind of procedural fog that only the highest court can produce. Sotomayor’s objection was blunt: while lawyers argue over which court has authority, a child is waiting to find out which adult is going to be allowed to love them on Tuesday.

Talk to FigletFigs’ AI relationship coachHere now, ready when you are

While you litigate custody, your child is caught in the middle.

Do you know you can get personalized answers to all your questions from the same wisdom that wrote this article, right now?

Ask anything about your own situation and get an answer immediately. Keep asking, think it through, work out what to do next.

No credit card required. Your first 10 messages are free.

Ask Figlet about fighting over your child.

The cultural response has been predictable. We debate the limits of judicial overreach. We analyze the jurisdictional arguments. We read the filings. We treat the collapse of a family as a legal puzzle.

But when I read a headline like this, I am not looking at the law. I am looking at a body in alarm. Two adult bodies in alarm, locked in what I call the Versus Illusion, and at least one small body caught in the middle, trying to make sense of why the two people it is biologically organized around have decided the other one is the enemy.

A couple in my office last week spent their entire session aggressively treating their children like line items in a legal contract. The husband sat rigidly on the couch, presenting a binder of documented visitation violations, threatening to have his lawyer file an emergency motion. His former wife sat on the far armrest, coldly explaining that she was seeking full physical custody to protect the children from his constant interference. I let them aggressively litigate their family dynamic for a few minutes before I gently stopped the conversation. I have watched this hundreds of times in my seventeen years of clinical practice. Family court lawyers and the legal system will constantly tell you that a custody battle is simply a logistical dispute that requires a rigid contract and a judge to declare a winner. As a clinician, I have to tell you that this common assumption completely misses the biological reality of your distress. When you fiercely weaponize a custody schedule against your former partner, you are almost never dealing with a legal problem. You are dealing with a profound limbic emergency.

To understand how a family system devolves into a courtroom battlefield, you must understand a severe negative cycle that I clinically call the Waltz of Pain. In this ancient survival system, your nervous system does not view the loss of your family structure as a simple administrative transition. It detects a literal, life threatening abandonment. When access to your children feels threatened, your amygdala fires and your prefrontal cortex goes entirely offline. One partner pursues relentlessly with aggressive legal demands to forcefully secure their connection. To the other partner, this intense legal pursuit feels like a suffocating wave of engulfment, triggering an equally fierce defensive reaction. You are not fighting over a calendar. You are fighting a neurobiological war where both parents use extreme legal armor to survive a crushing attachment wound.

I know exactly how devastating this biological panic can become because I grew up as the child of two broken homes, carrying my own childhood wounds of abandonment. While you are desperately trying to manage your shattered attachment system by heavily policing your former partner, your child’s nervous system is quietly absorbing the absolute terror of a divided world. A child’s biology keeps an immutable record of every single moment they feel safe or threatened by the emotional climate between their parents. The court system is built to assign visitation, but a judge absolutely cannot repair a terrified nervous system or force a parent to provide genuine emotional safety.

You simply cannot protect your children by treating your co-parenting relationship like a bitter corporate liquidation. If you want to understand what Justice Sotomayor’s recent custody dissent actually reveals about the devastating collision between family law and human attachment, we have to look entirely past the legal briefs to safely examine the hidden biological reality controlling the crisis.

The Peg Is Not the Point

The Empathi Quiz

Which pattern is running your relationship?

Take the free three minute quiz and meet the creature behind the cycle you keep getting stuck in.

Take the quiz

Sotomayor’s dissent matters. Jurisdictional chaos in custody disputes is a real problem, and she is right to name it. But the deeper story under every custody tug of war, including this one, is not legal. It is biological. And the legal system, by design, cannot resolve a biological emergency. It can only document one.

That is what I want to sit with you about today. Because if you are reading this while in your own custody fight, you need to understand what is actually happening under the hood. Not in the courthouse. In your body. In your ex’s body. In your child’s body. That is the ground where this is really being fought, and it is the only ground where anything like resolution is ever possible.

From Empathi’s own research: in 58,221 completed relationship assessments, shut down and withdraw were the top two reactive behaviours for withdrawers (8,653 and 7,743) and the second and third for pursuers (8,007 and 7,700).

See the full findings from 58,221 assessments

What Makes a Custody Battle High Conflict?

Every separation has conflict. Grief and anger are part of the ending of any bond. A custody case becomes high conflict when the conflict stops being about the issues and becomes the relationship itself. The fight is the only place the two of you still meet.

Family law writers and courts tend to describe the same signs, and I see the same ones in my office:

  • Litigation that never ends. Motion after motion, emergency filings, repeated requests to modify the parenting plan.
  • Communication has collapsed. Every text is a tripwire. Simple logistics take twenty messages and end in an accusation.
  • Serious allegations. Claims of abuse, neglect, substance use, or one parent turning the child against the other.
  • The child is in the middle. Used as a courier, a witness, a confidant, or evidence in the case each parent is quietly building.
  • Professionals multiply. Custody evaluators, guardians ad litem, parenting coordinators, court-ordered therapy.
  • Nobody can stand down. Both parents believe their safety depends on defeating the other.

That last one is the engine under all the others. It is what I call the Versus Illusion, and I will come back to it. But first, notice something. Not one of those signs is really about the calendar. The custody schedule is never about the custody schedule. The pickup time is never about the pickup time. The fight underneath is always one of two questions on loop: are you there for me, and am I enough for you? When the answer feels like no, the house catches fire. Not literally. Biologically.

The Cradle Problem Every Judge Inherits

We are born needing a primary attachment figure, from the cradle to the grave. That is not sentiment. That is mammalian biology. When a baby cries out, they are asking one question: is my good enough other there for me? That question never stops getting asked. It just gets asked in more sophisticated ways as we age.

When parents split, a child’s entire reference system is scrambled. The two humans whose presence their brain has been organizing itself around have suddenly become dangerous to each other. The child is now watching their secure base turn into a war zone. Their body registers this the way yours would register an earthquake. The ground is no longer ground.

The legal system approaches this as a logistics problem. Weekend schedules. Holiday rotations. School district assignments. Medical decision authority. These things matter, of course. But to a child’s body, custody is not a calendar. It is the question of whether the people who made them can stand being in the same room without the temperature dropping.

That is what a child actually needs. Not equal time. Not a perfectly drafted parenting plan. The felt sense that the two adults they love can be civil enough to let them love both.

How a High Conflict Custody Battle Affects Children

Here is the thing almost every parenting-through-divorce article gets wrong: the damage is rarely about the divorce itself. Kids are wildly adaptive. Two parents can uncouple romantically and still function as a secure parental floor. The child grieves, adjusts, and integrates. What breaks the child is when the two adults who used to be the floor stop functioning as a team and start functioning as opponents. When the floor becomes a battlefield, the child has nowhere left to stand.

The research has said this for a long time. Janet Johnston’s review of high conflict divorce in The Future of Children found that ongoing conflict between parents, together with a parent’s own emotional distress, predicted poorer parent and child relationships and more emotional and behavioural problems in children. Children do not metabolize the content of your words. They metabolize your regulation.

Kids do not tell you what they know. They show you. And what they show you almost never looks like grief in the way adults expect grief to look. It changes with age:

Babies and toddlers

A baby’s whole nervous system is organized around one question: is my good enough other there for me? When the adults holding them are flooded, sleep and feeding get disrupted, fussiness persists, and new skills can slide backward. They cannot understand a court date. They can feel a parent’s body bracing at every handoff.

School-age children

This is where I see the somatic ledger most clearly. Stomachaches on transition days. A regression in sleep. A new fear of the dark. A sudden preoccupation with whether the front door is locked. A child who used to run into the room and now watches your face first to see what the weather is. School-age kids are also the ones most likely to become the little diplomat, the confidant, the small judge in the middle of the courtroom, listening carefully to both cases and trying not to give anything away.

Teenagers

Teens often look fine. Suspiciously fine. Suspiciously easygoing, suspiciously accommodating. Some go the other way and act out, pull away from both homes, or pick a side hard so the war might finally stop. Underneath, many are making a quiet decision about what love is: that it calcifies into warfare, and that it is safer not to need anyone.

The loyalty bind

At every age, the deepest wound is the loyalty bind. A child in the middle of a two-parent war cannot hold both parents at once when those parents can no longer hold each other. And siding against one parent, even quietly, even in the story you tell yourself in the car, confirms the child’s unspoken sense that their own worth is negotiable. If half of them, the half that came from your ex, is bad, then half of them is bad. Kids do the math instantly. I go deeper into this in what is really happening when kids choose sides after divorce.

So when you ask, “How are they doing with all this?” and they say “fine,” and they are getting stomachaches on Tuesday nights, believe the stomach.

The Versus Illusion in Black Robes

In my clinical work I talk about something called the Versus Illusion. It is the specific blindness where two partners mistakenly believe their safety depends on defeating the other. It is not you versus me. It is us versus the dynamic that is trying to kill our connection. That framing is hard enough to hold inside a functioning marriage. It becomes almost impossible inside a legal proceeding designed to demand the opposite.

Family court is structurally incapable of teaching anything except the Versus Illusion. The entire apparatus is adversarial. Each party is required to construct a case for why the other one is less fit, less stable, less safe. Each party hires a professional storyteller whose job is to make the other parent look worse. Each filing deepens the narrative that the other one is the threat.

I have written before about the Third Chair, the empty seat at the table that holds everything you both claim to be fighting for. Your children. Your shared history. The emotional infrastructure your kids grow up inside. In every high conflict divorce, the Third Chair is the first casualty. Not because either parent wants to destroy it. Because the system they have entered is built to ignore it. The judge cannot see it. The attorneys are not paid to protect it. If you want the Chair to survive, you have to protect it yourself, often in direct opposition to the strategy your lawyer is recommending.

The Keynote Speakers at the Conference of Flaws

Here is something I have observed in my office for seventeen years. Every partner in a distressed relationship is the world’s leading expert on the problems of the other one. If you hosted a global conference on what is wrong with your ex, you would be the keynote speaker. You could give the lecture in your sleep. You already have, probably last night, at three a.m., to a pillow.

Family court is the institution built to host this exact conference. It is the only venue on earth where you can be paid in attention and validated in legal status for delivering the keynote about how wrong your former partner is. The affidavits, the motions, the testimony, these are all just formal versions of the speech you have been rehearsing in your head for months.

The trouble is that this conference never produces what you actually need. You think you are fighting for the schedule, the house, the decision authority. Underneath the content, your physiology is fighting something older and rawer. The terrifying feeling of being replaced. The shame of being deemed unfit. The grief of losing a future you planned on. The content is not what is actually at stake. What is at stake is the way your body is fighting about the content.

I wrote a whole piece about what happens when an ex keeps breaking the custody schedule, and the honest clinical truth is this: sometimes the schedule violations are not really about the schedule. They are about a person who has no other outlet to process that the relationship is over, so they use logistics as a proxy. Understanding the function of the behavior does not make it okay. But it can stop you from treating every missed pickup as a personal attack, which is the one thing guaranteed to deepen the loop.

What the Courtroom Cannot Do

Here is the piece I want you to really hear. A judge cannot settle the somatic ledger of a terrified child. A ruling cannot make your ex stop feeling abandoned. A final decree cannot convince your body that you are still a good parent, if underneath this whole process there is a secret fear you are not.

The legal system is a cognitive instrument. It issues rulings. It enforces orders. It divides assets and time. What it cannot do, what it was never designed to do, is touch the limbic panic underneath any of this. Limbic panic is not persuaded by paperwork. It only settles in the presence of another settled body.

This is the gap that destroys so many families. People walk into court expecting resolution and walk out with a document. The document is not resolution. It is an agreement about logistics. The part of you that is grieving, the part of your ex that is raging, the part of your child that is bracing, none of that is addressed by any piece of paper a judge signs.

Which is why, a year after the decree, the same fight is still happening. It has just moved into text messages, new girlfriend dynamics, school pickup standoffs, and holiday planning catastrophes. I have written elsewhere about what happens when a new partner enters the picture and is labeled as interfering, and almost always, the new person is not the real issue. They are the lightning rod for all the unfinished emotional business between the original two.

What Judges and Custody Evaluators Actually Look At

I am a couples and family therapist, not a lawyer, and custody law differs by state and country. For anything about your own case, talk to a family law attorney where you live. But I can tell you what the process tends to look like from the outside, because so many of the parents I sit with walk in expecting something it was never built to give them.

In the United States, courts decide custody under a “best interests of the child” standard. The factors vary by state. Florida’s custody statute, for example, asks the court to weigh things like each parent’s willingness to support the child’s relationship with the other parent, the stability of each home, and each parent’s conduct. Read that first one again. In many places, the parent who keeps the other parent in the child’s life is looking after their own case as well as their child.

In high conflict cases, the court often brings in neutral professionals. A custody evaluator, usually a psychologist, interviews both parents and the child, observes each parent with the child, and talks to teachers or doctors before making recommendations. A guardian ad litem may be appointed to represent the child’s best interests. Family law firms give the same practical advice again and again: follow the orders exactly, be reliable, keep the child out of adult matters, stay calm under provocation, and do not run down the other parent to the evaluator.

Here is my clinical translation of that advice. Everything the court is looking for is a regulated nervous system. The parent who can stay calm, keep the child out of the war, and hold the other parent’s place in the child’s heart is not just winning points. They are giving the child the one thing the child actually needs.

Court Involved Family Therapy, Reunification Therapy and Parenting Coordinators

When a case stays stuck, the court may order help. These terms get used loosely, so here is the plain version.

Court involved family therapy is therapy that happens because a court ordered it or because it is connected to a custody case. It might be therapy for the child, for one parent and the child, or for the family. The Association of Family and Conciliation Courts publishes guidelines for therapists doing this work, because the stakes are different: what is said may reach the court, and both parents may be watching for ammunition.

Reunification therapy is a form of court involved therapy aimed at repairing a relationship between a child and a parent that has become strained or broken, often a parent the child is refusing to see. Done well, it is slow and careful. It moves at the pace of the child’s nervous system and does not force contact that the child’s body experiences as danger.

A parenting coordinator is a neutral professional, often a therapist or attorney, appointed to help high conflict parents carry out their parenting plan and settle day-to-day disputes without going back to court every few weeks.

And co-parenting counseling is the voluntary version, where both of you choose to sit down with a therapist to work on how you raise your kids from two homes. I wrote a full piece on what to expect from co-parenting counseling. Whatever the label, the work I believe in is the same. Connection first, problem solving later. Not reconciliation. Just two bodies calm enough to stop feeding the loop.

Parental Alienation or a Child’s Real Fear?

This is the most painful corner of any high conflict custody battle, and I want to be careful with it. When a child refuses to see one parent, that parent often reaches for one word: alienation. Sometimes one parent really is turning a child against the other. Courts take that seriously. But sometimes a child’s refusal is genuine distress about what happens in that home, and sometimes it is something else entirely.

A child’s refusal is almost never simple. It could be real fear. It could be alignment with the parent who seems more fragile, more angry, or more likely to fall apart without them. It could be the child’s body voting against the transition itself, or a bid to end the war by removing one leg of the tripod so the whole unbearable structure can finally rest. None of these are ideology. None of these are betrayal.

So slow down before you interpret. If there is any question of abuse or danger, safety comes first, and that is a matter for professionals and the court. If not, get curious instead of building a case. Do not reward the refusal by making yourself the safe harbor from the other parent. And check whether your own body is quietly relieved when they refuse, because kids read that too.

What Shifted in One Driveway

A few years ago I worked with two co-parents. A doctor and a founder, divorced two years, sharing a seven-year-old. They came in because their son had started having stomachaches every Sunday night before the switch.

She was furious. He was constantly violating the schedule, bringing their son back forty minutes late, changing plans at the last minute, texting her critical notes about the boy’s diet under her roof. She wanted tighter boundaries. She wanted him locked out of decisions. She had a lawyer on speed dial. He was cold and rigid in session, answering in short sentences and explaining, patiently, that she was controlling and wanted to run him out of his own son’s life.

I asked him, gently, what happens in his body when he reads her long, precise texts about the schedule. He stared at the floor for a long time. Then he said, quietly: “My chest goes freezing cold. My throat closes up. I feel like a little kid who’s failed a test. I feel like I’m about to be told I’m not a real father.”

Her face changed. I watched it happen. The sharp, prosecutorial posture softened. She had spent two years seeing a stonewalling narcissist, and for the first time she saw a scared boy inside a man she used to love. When I asked her what happens in her body when he brings their son back late, she said she felt completely alone, like she was the only one holding this child and no one was coming.

Two suffering nervous systems. One story between them, told from two ends of the same rope. They did not become friends. They did not remarry. But something shifted in the driveway, and the stomachaches stopped. No motion, no evaluator and no app could have done that. A dropped defense on both sides, for the sake of the small body watching, did.

Two Suffering Bubbles, One Shared Dynamic

When a marriage collapses, both people are trapped in two separate suffering bubbles. One person feels abandoned. The other feels like they could never be good enough. One person is loud about their pain. The other is quiet and defended. From inside each bubble, the other person looks like the villain. From inside each bubble, the legal system looks like the solution.

My clinical work, even with couples who are divorcing, is not to validate one bubble over the other. It is to help them see that they are both inside the same weather. The goal is to move from two separate suffering bubbles into one shared relationship suffering bubble, where the dynamic between them becomes the thing they both acknowledge, even if they are no longer romantically involved. When both people can name that the loop itself is what hurt them, something loosens. Not love, necessarily. But the war loses some of its oxygen.

Family court keeps people in separate bubbles by design. It rewards the sharper story, the more damning evidence, the more compelling victim narrative. That is not a flaw in any particular judge. That is the structure. If you want out of the bubble, you will have to find the door yourself, because no one inside that building is incentivized to show it to you.

Empathy Cubed: The Only Real Exit

What I try to teach, in the office and in my forthcoming book, is something I call Empathy Cubed. Empathy for me. Empathy for you. Empathy for us, even when the us is now a co-parenting arrangement rather than a marriage.

Empathy for me means acknowledging your own exhaustion, your own fear, your own grief, without drowning in it. Empathy for you means looking at your ex and recognizing that their aggression, their withdrawal, their impossible demands are coming from a wound, not from entitlement. The walls are built of shame, not malice. And empathy for us means holding the Third Chair, the thing you both created, even when you no longer want to be in a room together.

Courtrooms forbid this posture. They demand you prove the other party is unfit. Empathy Cubed is the opposite move. It says: I can acknowledge my ex’s humanity without excusing their behavior. I can protect my child without weaponizing them. I can have a hard boundary and a soft heart in the same minute.

This is especially critical when the stakes are higher than usual. I have written about custody issues involving a special needs child, and the same principle applies with even more weight: can the two of you, in the midst of pain and separation, find a way to treat your child’s wellbeing as sacred ground? Not your marriage anymore. Not your grievance list. Just a shared commitment to something bigger than the individual hurt. That is the real labor of the bond. And nobody in black robes is going to do it for you.

What Your Child Is Actually Learning

There is a concept in developmental psychology called witnessed repair. It does not mean hiding conflict from your kids. It means showing them that two people who love each other can get hurt and find their way back to functioning.

If any of this is landing close to home, you can talk it through right now with Figlet, Figs’ AI relationship coach, and get an answer about your own situation in seconds. Ask Figlet about fighting over your child.

Your children are not tracking who wins the custody motion. They are tracking something much more primitive. Can my parents be in the same room? Can they text each other about me without it turning ugly? Can they attend the same recital without me having to manage their emotions? That is the somatic inheritance you are leaving them. Not the square footage at each house. The felt sense of whether rupture can be repaired.

Every text message you send, every choice to escalate or de-escalate, every moment you resist the temptation to run a whisper campaign through your kid, all of it is building or dismantling the template they will carry into every relationship they ever have.

How to Talk to Your Kids During a Custody Battle

Your children do not need the case. They need the floor. Children are not the appropriate audience for your case against their other parent, however true it is. The impulse to correct the record with your kids is almost always the adult’s own shame looking for a witness. Save the truth for your attorney, your therapist, your journal, or a trusted friend.

What helps, in simple, age-appropriate words:

  • “Mom and Dad are working out grown-up decisions about where you live. That is our job, not yours.”
  • “This is not because of anything you did. Nothing you did caused it, and nothing you do has to fix it.”
  • “You are allowed to love both of us. You never have to choose.”
  • When they bring something hard back from the other house: “That sounds really hard to hear. I love you, and I am here.”

What never to do: ask them what happened over there, ask them to keep secrets, ask who they want to live with, carry messages between houses, read them court papers, or let them see the tightness in your face after a text comes through. One must be the parent. One must be the child. The moment that reverses, the child learns to survive by becoming hyper-independent, hyper-attuned, and quietly alone.

Parallel Parenting: The Structure for High Conflict

When two parents cannot be near each other without the temperature dropping, the usual recommendation is parallel parenting. Contact is cut down to the essentials, communication happens in writing, each parent runs their own household, and exchanges happen at school or a neutral spot. Major decisions about health, education and safety are still shared, usually through the written parenting plan.

I want to be honest about this. Parallel parenting is the right container when you are dealing with a dangerous ex, meaning coercion, contempt, or unsafety that does not respond to any invitation toward repair. Then a wall is not avoidance. It is protection. But most parents I sit with are dealing with a difficult ex, wounded and reactive but capable of moments of repair, and are being told by the internet that they are in the dangerous category. If that is you, use parallel parenting as scaffolding while things are hot, not as a permanent wall, and keep the door open to more as the system settles. I lay out the full comparison in parallel parenting vs co-parenting.

How to Stay Regulated and Protect Yourself

You need two things at once in a high conflict custody battle: a clean record and a settled body. They are not in conflict. The calm parent usually has the cleaner record.

Document like a scientist, not a prosecutor. Keep a dated, plain log of what actually happened: missed exchanges, late pickups, what was said, school and medical events. Facts, not adjectives. Write it, close it, and walk away. If the log becomes the place you rehearse the case against your ex at midnight, it has stopped protecting you and started running you.

Keep written replies brief and neutral. Bill Eddy of the High Conflict Institute teaches a method called BIFF: responses that are Brief, Informative, Friendly and Firm. No defending yourself in detail, no receipts, no sarcasm. Assume a judge will read every message, because one might.

Buy yourself the fifteen seconds. When you are in a heated exchange, your neocortex is running behind your amygdala, and for a few seconds you simply cannot stop your reactivity. Read the text, notice your chest, put the phone down, and reply when your adult self is back online.

Keep seventy five percent of your awareness on yourself. That is what I teach parents in session. If your focus is entirely locked onto what the other person is doing wrong, you have left your own body, and your child is downstream of that.

How to De-escalate With the Other Parent

You cannot control what happens in the other house. You can stop feeding the loop on your side. The Waltz of Pain needs two dancers, and when one of you stops taking the step, the whole dance slows down.

That might mean answering a provocation with one logistical sentence. It might mean letting a missed pickup be a scheduling problem instead of a referendum on your worth. And if there is ever enough safety, it might mean naming the loop instead of the person: “I notice whenever we get near school decisions, we end up here. I don’t want to be here either.” That sentence, if it can be spoken and received, is worth more than any parenting plan a court can draft.

Application: You Are Sitting in One of These Chairs Right Now

If you are reading this in the middle of your own custody fight, I want you to slow down for a moment. Put the legal brief aside. Step out of the Versus Illusion just long enough to ask yourself an honest question.

What are you actually fighting for? If it is your child’s wellbeing, then every move has to be evaluated against the Third Chair. Does this motion protect the emotional infrastructure my child lives inside, or does it shred it further? Does this text message teach them that rupture can be repaired, or that love calcifies into warfare? Does this legal strategy win me a tactical point at the cost of seventeen years of my child’s capacity to trust?

The court cannot answer these questions for you. Your lawyer is not trained to. Your rage, however justified, will not guide you here. The only thing that will is the slow, unglamorous practice of returning to your own settled body, over and over, in moments when every cell in you wants to swing.

This is not a you problem or a them problem

“When two insecurely attached people interact, their protector strategies collide to form a negative feedback loop I call the Waltz of Pain. Your protector meets your partner’s protector. Their protector meets yours. Two childhood strategies collide, and the relationship becomes a reenactment of wounds neither partner caused.”

“Neither partner is the villain. They are two younger selves inside adult bodies trying to stay safe in the only ways they once knew.”

Figs O’Sullivan, LMFT

What to Do Tonight

If any of this is landing, start with something small and concrete. You do not have to fix the case tonight. Just these:

  1. Do not send the text tonight. Write it in your notes app if you have to. Read it again in the morning and cut it down to brief, informative, friendly and firm.
  2. Give your body sixty seconds. Put your hand on your chest. Notice what is tight, what is cold, where the throat is closing. Stay with it without moving to a story.
  3. Log today’s facts, then close the file. Dates, times, what happened. No adjectives. Then shut it, and do not reopen it before bed.
  4. Give your child one sentence. “You are allowed to love both of us.” If they overheard anything today, add: “That was grown-up stuff. It is not your job.”
  5. Do not gather intelligence. No questions about what happened at the other house tonight. Let them just be a kid in your kitchen.

Between court dates and custody exchanges, Figlet, my AI relationship coach, is what I have been building for people in exactly your position. People who cannot get their ex into a therapy room, cannot afford another attorney’s hour, cannot wait weeks for a session but need a steady voice at two in the morning when the custody exchange went sideways and they are about to send a text they will regret. It is trained on seventeen years of my clinical work, available when you actually need it.

Common Questions About High Conflict Custody Battles

What is considered a high conflict custody case?

A custody case is usually called high conflict when the dispute keeps returning to court, communication between the parents has broken down, there are serious allegations, and the children are pulled into the middle. The defining feature is that the conflict has become the relationship. It is no longer about solving a problem. It is about not losing to the other parent.

How does a high conflict custody battle affect children?

Children are affected less by the divorce itself than by ongoing conflict between their parents. It shows up in the body first: stomachaches on transition days, sleep regression, clinginess, hypervigilance, and in older kids, either acting out or a suspicious over-competence. The loyalty bind, feeling they must choose one parent, is often the deepest wound.

How do you win a high conflict custody battle?

Get a good family law attorney for the legal side, and on the human side, become the regulated parent. Courts generally look at the child’s best interests, including whether each parent supports the child’s relationship with the other parent. Follow orders exactly, keep the child out of adult matters, communicate briefly in writing, and document facts calmly. The parent who can stay settled is protecting both the case and the child.

What do judges look for in a custody case?

Standards vary by state, but most US courts use a best interests of the child test. Common factors include the stability of each home, each parent’s involvement and conduct, the child’s needs, any history of violence or abuse, and each parent’s willingness to support the child’s bond with the other parent. Your attorney can tell you how your jurisdiction applies them.

What is reunification therapy?

Reunification therapy is a form of court involved therapy meant to repair a strained or broken relationship between a child and a parent, often when the child is resisting contact. Good reunification work goes at the pace of the child’s nervous system and screens carefully for real safety concerns before pushing contact.

What is court involved family therapy?

Court involved family therapy is any therapy connected to a custody case, often ordered by a judge. It may involve the child, one parent and the child, or the whole family. Because information can reach the court, the therapist’s role and what stays confidential should be made clear at the start.

Should I tell my child about the custody case?

Tell them only what they need to feel safe: that the adults are working out where they will live, that it is not their fault, and that they are allowed to love both parents. Do not share court details, allegations, or your case against the other parent. Kids need a floor, not a briefing.

Is parallel parenting better for high conflict custody?

Parallel parenting is a legitimate container when the other parent is genuinely unsafe or never bends toward repair. For most difficult but not dangerous co-parents, it works best as temporary scaffolding while things cool down, with room to move toward more cooperation later. The damage to kids comes less from the model and more from what leaks around it: the tone at exchanges, the loaded silences.

How long does a high conflict custody battle last?

Legal timelines vary widely, and high conflict cases can return to court for years after the first order. In my clinical experience, the first eighteen months to two years after a separation are the hardest, because both nervous systems are still calibrated to the intact bond. Things usually ease when at least one parent stops feeding the cycle.

The Courtroom Writes the Order

A Supreme Court justice can name the failure of the system. That matters. But she cannot settle your child’s body, and she cannot settle yours. That work is yours to do, in your own living room, with your own body, every time you choose the harder move over the satisfying one. The courtroom writes the order. You build what your children inherit.

Keep Reading

Attachment

My Husband Withdraws When I Need Him Most: What’s Actually Happening Underneath

Attachment

My Husband Won’t Take Responsibility: What’s Actually Happening Underneath the Defensiveness

Attachment

My Husband Belittles Me in Front of Others: What’s Actually Happening Underneath

The Empathi Quiz

Every couple has a pattern they cannot see. Find yours.

In love, each of you is a Relentless or a Reluctant, which makes you one of three kinds of couple: Relentless and Reluctant, two Relentless, or two Reluctant. The free quiz reveals your creatures and the cycle they fall into together. About three minutes.

About three minutesCompletely freeBuilt on EFT science
Take the Empathi quiz

No signup needed to start.

The Relentless

The Reluctant

Which one are you?
Share this article

Figs O'Sullivan is a Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist (LMFT #79062) and the founder of Empathi. For 17 years he has helped couples move out of disconnection and back into secure, loving connection, drawing on Emotionally Focused Therapy and attachment science. With his wife Teale, he runs a San Francisco couples therapy practice, is a relationship expert to the Stars and Silicon Valley, and built Figlet, an AI relationship coach trained on their clinical work. His approach has guided more than 58,000 relationship assessments.

Related Articles

Scroll to Top
Share "When the Courtroom Meets the Cradle: What Justice Sotomayor’s Custody Dissent Reveals About the Biology of Broken Families"
Reading this from the Bay Area? Figs and Teale see couples in person at 999 Sutter Street in San Francisco, and online across California. Free 30-minute consult
Man smiling and meditating in a therapy session setting.
Figs, Teale & Figlet
● Available 24/7
You’re not alone.
Neither is your relationship. Talk to us right now, any time.
Start coaching with Figlet
First 10 messages free. No credit card required.
Request a Free Consultation
Figlet is Figs in an AI bottle
Not sure where to start? Take the 3-minute quiz ›
Man smiling and meditating in a therapy session setting.
Ask Figlet AI
Empathi couple illustration

Before you go: curious about your relationship pattern?

Take a free 3-minute quiz and discover whether you tend to pursue or withdraw in conflict. You'll get a personalized report.

Take the Free Quiz → 13 questions • 100% free • No email required
Couples therapy session with Figs O'Sullivan, focusing on relationship counseling.

Learn the method that transforms relationships

Join the Empathi Method Masterclass, a self-paced online course built on attachment science by Figs & Teale O'Sullivan.

Explore the Masterclass → Self-paced • Science-backed • Start today
Empathi couple illustration Couples therapy session with Figs O'Sullivan, focusing on relationship counseling.

Get relationship insights in your inbox

Join our newsletter for science-backed tips on connection, conflict, and lasting love.

Free • No spam • Unsubscribe anytime