My Husband Won’t Go to Couples Therapy. What Do I Say?

You have asked. Maybe you have asked five times. Gently, then not gently, then in the middle of a fight with the word divorce somewhere near it. And he says no. Or he says we do not need a stranger. Or he says fine and then never books it. Or he says nothing and picks up his phone, which is its own kind of no.

So now you are the one carrying the whole thing. You are reading the articles. You are doing the quizzes. You know the words for what is wrong and he will not even sit in a room with you and a stranger for an hour. And somewhere in you, a quiet voice has started saying, if he will not even do this, what does that tell me.

I am a couples therapist and I have spent twenty years getting reluctant men through my door. So let me tell you what is actually going on with him, and then the one thing to say, because it is not the thing you have been saying.

Why he will not come

He is not refusing because he does not care. In my office, the man who refuses therapy is almost always the one who cares so much that the thought of it is unbearable.

Here is what therapy looks like from inside his head. He already suspects he is failing you. He may never say that, but it is in there, burning. He knows you are disappointed and he does not know how to describe what is going on in him, so he goes to the place he feels competent, which is his work, or his logic, or his phone. Then you ask him to go and sit in a room with a professional, and to him that is walking into a place where a stranger will hand him a report card with straight Fs. Where you and the therapist will be on one side of the room and he will be on the other. Where he will be told, in nicer words, that he is the problem.

And if he has been to a therapist before who acted like a referee, or handed out worksheets, or sided with the person doing the talking, then he has proof. See. Therapy does not work.

Nobody wants to pay money to sit in a room and be told they are an asshole. I would not go either.

What it feels like to be him

I know this from the inside. When my wife points out where I have dropped the ball, my first instinct is not to be a wise couples therapist. It is to get defensive, explain my logic, and turn into what she calls Mr. Blamey Pants. I also know what it is like to hide behind a suit. At twenty-three I wore a tailored one to work in a bank in San Francisco to hide how poor and ashamed I felt. So when a man sits on my couch with his arms folded refusing to open up, I do not see a stubborn guy. I see myself in that suit, petrified of being found out as not enough.

Men are raised to live upstairs, in the part of the building where logic and problem-solving live. Therapy asks them to go down to the basement where the hurt is, and they have never been shown the stairs. When you ask him to go, what he hears is an invitation to jump off the roof without a parachute.

What not to say

I am going to be blunt because I have watched these three sink the thing before it started.

Do not sentence him. Six months. Twenty sessions. A commitment. To a man who is already afraid, that is a prison term.

Do not bring the case. Not the list of his failures. Not the article you read that says he is avoidant. Not the diagnosis from the internet. The moment therapy is a weapon to fix him, he is right to refuse it, and some part of him knows that.

Do not ask in the fight. Never. Nothing you say while both of your nervous systems are on fire will land, and you need therapy or we are getting a divorce, shouted at eleven at night, is a threat, not an invitation.

The one ask that works

This is what I tell every woman who sits in my office alone because he would not come.

Ask for one hour. Not a commitment. An experiment. Something like:

Would you do one sixty-minute session with me, as a gift to me? If it feels like a courtroom, or like you are being ganged up on, I promise we walk out and we never go back.

And then say why. Not the story of him, the story of you:

I am not asking for therapy so someone can fix you or tell you that you are wrong. I am asking because I feel lonely, I feel far away from you, and I am scared we are losing each other. I cannot do this without you.

Then, and this is the bit that gets him in the door, tell him you want to look at your part. I want to look at how I chase and criticise and push you away, just as much as anything you do. If it is going to be about the cycle you are both in and not about him, he can risk it. Most men can risk one hour.

What I say to him, if he is reading this over your shoulder

This is not a courtroom. I am not going to judge you and I will never let anyone gang up on you in my room. My job is to hold your experience with exactly the same respect as hers. Your shutting down is not coldness. It is your wobbly way of managing the unbearable feeling that you are failing the person who matters most to you. It makes total sense. Give me one hour and I will show you the pattern the two of you are caught in. If you feel put on trial, do not come back.

If he still says no

Here is the thing nobody tells you. You do not need him in the room to change the cycle.

A cycle takes two people doing their moves to keep spinning. If you stop bringing the investigations, put down the brief, stop building the case, and instead say the raw thing, I miss you, I feel scared, his threat drops. He does not have to run to the basement, because there is nothing coming at him. And when one person changes their move, the whole system has to recalibrate. It cannot not.

It is not fair that it falls to you. I know. But it works, and it works faster than you would think, and the man who would not come to therapy in March is often the one asking about it in May, because the room at home stopped feeling like a trial.

If you want help with the words for tonight, that is what I built Figlet for. Tell it what you have said to him about therapy and what he said back. It will show you the cycle and give you the one ask, in your words, that does not sound like a sentence.

Keep Reading

Photo by Sean Mungur on Unsplash

Articles

How I Knew I Needed Help

Photo by Seyed Amir Mohammad Tabatabaee on Unsplash

Articles

I’m Estranged From My Family

Articles

Why Do I Miss My Boyfriend So Much?