When Kids Prefer Living with the Other Parent...

When Kids Prefer Living with the Other Parent

Come here to me.

That one lands hard, doesn’t it? When a child says, or you sense, or someone tells you, that your kid would rather be with the other parent. That hits a place that is just… ancient. Like something underneath your ribs just drops.

I’ve sat with dozens of parents through this exact moment. The phone call where your eight-year-old asks if they can stay at Dad’s an extra night. The casual mention that Mom’s house is “more fun.” The mediator telling you your teenager wants to switch primary custody. Every single one of these parents thought it meant they had failed.

Here’s what I want you to hear: your nervous system is going to want to make that preference mean something about your worth as a parent. And I need you to be really careful there. Because that’s not what it means.

Kids are not relationship therapists. They’re not making a verdict on you as a human being. They’re telling you something about comfort, about ease, about where things feel less complicated right now. That’s developmental information. It’s not a court ruling on your value.

But here’s the real thing I want you to sit with. The shame that gets activated when you hear that your child prefers somewhere else? That shame has roots. And if you go digging, a lot of what you’ll find isn’t actually about your kid at all. It’s about an older story you carry about whether you’re enough. Whether you’re worthy of love and belonging. And what your child’s preference does is walk right into that room and knock everything off the shelves.

What I know about shame is that it sends us spinning in predictable directions. You can attack yourself (“I’m a terrible parent”). You can attack the other parent (“They’re buying the kids’ affection”). You can deny the whole thing is a problem (“Kids don’t know what they want anyway”). Or you can collapse (“I guess I should just give up”).

Notice which one you’re being pulled toward right now. Because none of those four will actually help your kid. Or you.

The way through is to be willing to feel the vulnerability of it, name it honestly, and not make your child responsible for carrying your pain about it. That last part is crucial. Your kid should never feel like they hurt you by having feelings about where they want to be.

And I’ll tell you something else. The repair that’s available to you here, showing up consistently, staying warm, not making your child pay for the preference, not weaponizing guilt – that’s the real proof of work of love. That’s where trust gets built. Not in the moments when everything is easy and your kid is choosing you. In the moments when it’s hard and you choose them anyway.

So come here. Take a breath. You’re not failing. You’re in one of the harder chapters of parenting. And what you do next matters enormously.

Where Does Your Relationship Stand?

Take the free Empathi Wisdom Score assessment. In 5 minutes, get a personalized snapshot of your relationship patterns and what to do about them. Take the free attachment style quiz to learn more.

Take the Free Assessment

About Figs O’Sullivan, LMFT
Figs is a licensed marriage and family therapist with 16+ years of experience working with couples. He’s the co-founder of Empathi, host of the “Come Here to Me” podcast, and author of an upcoming book on relationships and the systems that shape how we love.

Read more: Co-Parenting After Divorce: What to Expect from Counseling

Share this article

Fiachra "Figs" O’Sullivan is a renowned couples therapist and the founder of Empathi.com. He believes the principles of secure attachment and sound money are the two essential protocols for building a future filled with hope. A husband and dad, he lives in Hawaii, where he’s an outrigger canoe paddler, getting humbled daily by the wind and waves. He’s also incessantly funny, to the point that he should probably see someone about that.

Related Articles

Scroll to Top
Share "When Kids Prefer Living with the Other Parent"
Empathi couple illustration

Before you go — curious about your relationship pattern?

Take a free 3-minute quiz and discover whether you tend to pursue or withdraw in conflict. You'll get a personalized report.

Take the Free Quiz → 13 questions • 100% free • No email required
Figs and Teale O'Sullivan

Learn the method that transforms relationships

Join the Empathi Method Masterclass — a self-paced online course built on attachment science by Figs & Teale O'Sullivan.

Explore the Masterclass → Self-paced • Science-backed • Start today
Empathi couple illustration Figs and Teale

Get relationship insights in your inbox

Join our newsletter for science-backed tips on connection, conflict, and lasting love.

Free • No spam • Unsubscribe anytime

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does it hurt so much when my child prefers their other parent?+
That pain hits so deep because your nervous system is detecting what feels like abandonment by the person who matters most. We're all babies in love, even with our kids. When they choose the other parent, your body interprets it as an existential threat to the bond. It's not about logic (you know they still love you), it's about that ancient part of your brain screaming that you're being rejected. This is childlike, not childish. Your nervous system doesn't know the difference between your kid wanting to stay at Dad's an extra night and actual abandonment. The pain is real and normal.
Does my child preferring their other parent mean I'm a bad parent?+
Absolutely not. Your nervous system wants to make their preference mean something about your worth, but preferences are often about logistics, not love. Maybe the other house has fewer rules right now, or different friends nearby, or they're testing boundaries. Kids aren't relationship therapists making careful assessments of parenting quality. They're navigating their own survival needs, which might have nothing to do with your actual parenting. The versus illusion makes you think it's you against your ex, but really, you're both just trying to love this kid through an impossible situation.
How do I handle my emotions when my child wants to live with their other parent?+
First, let yourself feel the pain without making it mean you've failed. Your body is having a normal response to perceived rejection. Then remember that your child's preference isn't a referendum on your love or worth. They're trying to navigate a split world that adults created, and they're doing their best too. Focus on staying connected rather than controlling where they sleep. Keep showing up with consistency and presence, not desperation. If you're really struggling with this, Figlet, our AI relationship coach, can help you process these feelings and develop responses that protect both your heart and your relationship with your child.