Here’s the honest answer, and I know it’s not the one you’re hoping for: it takes longer than you think it should. It always does.
I’ve sat with hundreds of couples going through exactly this, and the number one thing I see is that the person who did the betraying has a timeline in their head, and that timeline is almost always wrong. They’re thinking months. The reality is often years. And even that’s not a clean finish line where someone stamps “trusted again” on your forehead.
Here’s what I know rebuilds trust. It’s not just time on its own. It’s time multiplied by consistency of behavior, multiplied by transparency. All three together. You take any one of those out of the equation and the math doesn’t work.
And the transparency piece, that’s the hard one for people to swallow. If you were the one who betrayed, you may now be in a situation where your partner wants to look at your phone. And something in you is going to bristle at that. It’s going to feel like a violation of who you are. And I want you to understand something: that feeling makes sense, AND your partner’s need to check makes sense too. You are in a new relationship now. There is a before and after. The rules changed.
What I always tell the person who did the betraying is this: stop trying to rush back to good. I know you feel terrible. I know you want this to be over. But every time you signal impatience, every time you say “aren’t you over this yet,” you are actually making it take longer. Because what your partner needs to see is not that you’re sorry. They need to see that you get it. Really get it. That you understand the ground got pulled out from under them, that their whole reality had to be rewritten, and that you’re not going anywhere while they put it back together piece by piece.
The affair wasn’t one betrayal, by the way. I want you to hear that. It was many. There’s the act itself, the lying, the gaslighting, the shame, the “who else knew,” the rewriting of every memory. Those are six or seven separate wounds, and each one needs attention. So if it feels like you keep going over the same ground, that’s why.
What transformed looks like, in the couples I’ve seen actually get there, is not “we put it behind us.” It looks more like: “I know you’re going to get scared again, and when you do, I’m going to be right here.” It’s not forgetting. It’s integrating. You don’t get a table for two anymore. You get a table for four, because those hurt parts of both of you are coming to dinner too, and you learn to love them.
Is that harder than just “getting over it”? Yes. Is it more real? Absolutely.
Where Does Your Relationship Stand?
Take the free Empathi Wisdom Score assessment. In 5 minutes, get a personalized snapshot of your relationship patterns and what to do about them.
Figs is a licensed marriage and family therapist with 16+ years of experience working with couples. He’s the co-founder of Empathi, host of the “Come Here to Me” podcast, and author of an upcoming book on relationships and the systems that shape how we love.
Explore More Topics
